[virt-tools-list] [PATCH virt-viewer v2] Add some multimonitor documentation

Tue Nov 3 16:58:25 UTC 2015

These two files describe some of the behavior and requirements for
virt-viewer in fullscreen multimonitor mode
---

Changes since v1: 
 - settings: G: specify that 'sparse' guest display configurations are invalid
 - requirements: D4: client doesn't restrict initial size, but WM might

 docs/multimonitor-fullscreen-settings | 140 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 docs/multimonitor-requirements        |  98 ++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 238 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 docs/multimonitor-fullscreen-settings
 create mode 100644 docs/multimonitor-requirements

diff --git a/docs/multimonitor-fullscreen-settings b/docs/multimonitor-fullscreen-settings
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..7ec4432
--- /dev/null
+++ b/docs/multimonitor-fullscreen-settings
@@ -0,0 +1,140 @@
+=================================================================
+File Format
+=================================================================
+
+The configuration file is a GKeyFile format file.  The GUID is
+the 'group' name, and the mapping configuration for the guest is
+specified with a 'monitor-mapping' key. The 'monitor-mapping' key
+is an array of mappings from display ID to monitor ID. Since
+GKeyFile uses ';' as an array separator, we use ':' as the
+mapping separator. Display and monitor IDS both use 1-based
+indices (i.e. the first display is 1, not 0).
+
+So, to map guest display 1 to client monitor 1, use "1:1".  To
+map guest display 1 to client monitor 2 and guest display 2 to
+client monitor 3, use "1:2;2:3".
+
+Fallback configuration is specified in the same manner, but uses
+the group name 'fallback'.
+
+=================================================================
+A. Basic example
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:2
+
+A1. When connecting to guest 6485b... on a client with 2
+monitors, it will enable only guest display #1 and display it on
+monitor #2.
+
+A2. When connecting to guest 6485b... on a client with 1 monitor,
+the "1:2" mapping refers to a non-existant monitor and will thus
+be ignored (C4). Because there are no valid display mappings
+specified, the configuration will be considered invalid (B13).
+The guest will then be displayed according to the default
+behavior (open 1 display on monitor 1)
+
+A3. When connecting to any other guest, it will use default
+behavior (enable 1 display for each monitor and map them N:N)
+
+
+=================================================================
+B. Basic example with fallback
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:2
+  
+  [fallback]
+  monitor-mapping=1:2;2:3;3:4
+
+B1. same as A1
+
+B2. same as A2
+
+B3. When connecting to another guest on a client with 4 monitors:
+it will enable 3 displays and assign them to monitors 2, 3 and 4.
+
+B4. When connecting to another guest on a client with 3 monitors:
+it will enable 2 displays and assign them to monitors 2 and 3
+
+B5. When connecting to another guest on a client with 1 monitor:
+no mappings are valid, so default behavior will be used.
+
+
+=================================================================
+C. Same display referenced multiple times
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;1:2
+
+C1. configuration is invalid because it is ambiguous (display 1
+is mapped to both monitor 1 and monitor 2).  Default behavior
+will be used.
+
+
+=================================================================
+D. Same monitor referenced multiple times
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;2:1
+
+D1. configuration is invalid because it is ambiguous (both guest
+display 1 and guest display 2 and mapped to monitor 1).  Default
+behavior will be used.
+
+
+=================================================================
+E. Multiple configurations for same GUID
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;2:2
+  
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:2;2:3
+
+E1. Since two configurations are given for the same guest, the
+last one will be used. Two guest displays will be enabled and
+will be shown on monitors 2 and 3
+
+
+=================================================================
+F. multiple monitor-mapping keys for same GUID
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;2:2
+  monitor-mapping=1:2;2:3
+
+F1. Since two configurations are given for the same guest, the
+last one will be used. Two guest displays will be enabled and
+will be shown on monitors 2 and 3
+
+
+=================================================================
+G. 'sparse' displays
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;3:2
+
+G1. configuration is invalid. Enabled guest displays must be
+specified without any gaps between displays.
+
+
+=================================================================
+H. configuration specifies more displays than guest can enable
+=================================================================
+
+  [6485b20f-e9da-614c-72b0-60a7857e7886]
+  monitor-mapping=1:1;2:2;3:3
+
+H1. If guest 6485b... is a windows guest with only 2 display
+devices, we will enable displays 1 and 2 on the guest, and assign
+them to monitors 1 and 2 (respectively) on the client.  Guest
+display 3 will be disabled.
+
diff --git a/docs/multimonitor-requirements b/docs/multimonitor-requirements
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..fdffdf7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/docs/multimonitor-requirements
@@ -0,0 +1,98 @@
+Fullscreen Startup Mode
+-----------------------
+A. Default fullscreen behavior
+  Assume:
+      NG = number of displays supported by the guest
+      NC = number of monitors on the client
+      N = the lesser of NG and NC
+  A1. at startup, enable N displays on the guest
+  A2. if N == NC, map guest display X to physical monitor X
+  A3. if N < NC, map guest display X to physical monitor X+1 (the primary
+    monitor likely has an application menu, etc, so keep that free for local use)
+  A4. Arrange guest displays in the same geometry as the physical monitors
+
+B. Custom monitor mapping configuration
+  B1. configuration file is specific to a particular user on a particular client
+      machine.  Different users on same machine can use different
+      configurations.
+  B2. configuration only applies to fullscreen startup mode
+  B3. configuration should be simple to edit by hand
+  B4. It must be possible to specify a custom configuration for a specific
+      guest vm
+  B5. guest-specific configuration is identified by GUID
+  B6. It must be possible to specify a fallback configuration that will be used
+      for all guests without an explicit configuration
+  B7. It must be possible to specify how many guest displays to enable
+  B8. It must be possible to specify which guest display to map to which to
+      client monitor
+  B9. configuration format must be flexible and support a wide range of guest
+      and client configurations
+  B10. if the guest-specific configuration is invalid, we will attempt to use
+      the default/fallback configuration
+  B11. if the fallback configuration is invalid, we will revert to default
+      behavior (see A)
+  B12. Configuration must be considered invalid if it is not unambiguous
+  B13. A configuration that doesn't specify any displays will be considered
+      invalid
+  B14. if multiple configurations are given for the same guest, the last one
+      will be used.
+
+  - non-requirements (these are features that were considered but I propose that
+    they are explicitly not supported)
+    - no need to have separate configurations depending on how many guest
+      displays are currently enabled
+      - complicates startup (have to wait to receive display config before
+        setting up anything)
+      - complicates config file format
+      - the number of guest displays may have been set by another user since you
+        last logged in, so it's not clear to me that we want to make
+        configuration decisions based on something you can't control
+    - no need to specify the geometry arrangement of displays
+      - just match the arrangement of the physical monitors that the display
+        will be mapped to
+    - no need to specify different guest configurations based on client
+      configuration (e.g. separate guest configurations for when the client
+      machine has 4 monitors vs when it has 2 monitors)
+      - complicates config file format
+      - possibly unnecessary if we satisfy B9
+
+  - Implications of high-level requirements
+    1. per-guest display mapping will always work with virt-viewer because
+       virt-viewer can get the GUID from libvirt <B5>
+    2. per-guest display mapping may not work with *remote-viewer* in many cases.
+       If you're connecting to a vm on a host that is running an older version
+       of spice-server (e.g. RHEL6), the GUID is not sent over the spice
+       protocol, so remote-viewer doesn't have any way of determining a guest's
+       GUID <B5>
+
+  - Derived requirements
+    C1. Use GKeyFile <B3>
+    C2. need to add a 'Guest Details' dialog to virt-viewer so that the user can
+        determine the GUID of the guest. <B3><B5>
+    C3. if config file specifies more guest displays than can be enabled on the
+        guest, simply ignore (disable) the extra displays <B9>
+    C4. if config file specifies that a display should be mapped to a client
+        monitor that doesn't exist, that display will not be enabled <B9>
+    C5. if config file specifies that a given guest display will map to multiple
+        client monitors, it will be considered invalid <B12>
+    C6. if the config file specifies that multiple guest displays will map to the
+        same client monitor, it will be considered invalid <B12>
+
+
+Normal (non-fullscreen) Startup Mode
+------------------------------------
+  D1. Client must not change Guest configuration at startup
+  D2. Client must open a window for every display that is enabled on the guest
+  D3. Client should allow the native window manager to place the display windows
+      at appropriate positions
+  D4. Client will not prevent displays from being larger than client monitors,
+      but the window manager may impose some size restrictions.
+  D5. Toggling fullscreen mode after startup should only affect the window that
+      was acted upon
+      - currently if client is started in fullscreen mode, exiting fullscreen
+        mode for one window will also exit fullscreen mode for all other windows
+        -- that will need to be changed.
+      - (If fullscreen toggle worked at the application level rather than the
+        window level, it's much more difficult to decide what to do if there are
+        more windows open than client monitors. It's easier to leave those sorts
+        of policy decisions to the user.)
-- 
2.4.3


